Investigation of a Citizen Above Justice

Investigation of a Citizen Above Justice

by Stephen Cox | Posted September 18, 2016

I'm not sure why Hillary Clinton does anything she does, but I know she has a way of reminding me of old movies. Gangster movies, of course -- though not the Godfather kind, in which you're supposed to sympathize with the profound psychological and metaphysical conflicts of the leading characters. No one actually sympathizes with Hillary Clinton. I'm reminded more of the primitive gangster films, which teach you that some guys just want to be king of the world and will do anything to reach the peak, or preserve the illusion.

Those aren't the only movies I associate with her. She often makes me think of His Girl Friday, where Earl Williams, the goofy gunman, is involved in so many ridiculous and, as Donald Trump would say, unbelievable incidents that a newspaper reporter says, "I'm pretending there ain't any Earl Williams." It's a relief to pretend that there ain't any Hillary Clinton.

Clinton violated the law, grossly, repeatedly, and ridiculously. She then told a long string of gross and ridiculous lies.

But the strongest cinematic parallel I can find to the Clinton story is a once-famous Italian movie that is called in English Investigation of a Citizen Above Suspicion (1970). In it, a ranking police officer commits a crime and then gets the idea of establishing his superiority to normal people by submitting to an investigation that shows he is guilty -- obviously guilty -- yet does not lead to his arrest.

The parallel with Clinton is evident. In the emails episode alone, Clinton violated the law, grossly, repeatedly, and ridiculously. She then told a long string of gross and ridiculous lies, all of them conflicting preposterously with common sense, and with one another. The FBI, led by the vaunted Mr. Comey, spent thousands of hoursinvestigating her, located (without any difficulty) the incriminating facts, listened to many additional ridiculous lies, and discovered that Citizen Clinton could not be prosecuted because there was no evidence she intended to violate any of the laws she schemed to violate.

That's basically how the Italian movie turns out. The power structure can never conceive of indicting one of its own. The bad guy wins -- in two ways, one of them more important to him (and to me) than the other. He doesn't get indicted; that's the relatively unimportant win. The more important one is his demonstration that people like him are above the law. Members of the elite are never punished; they are immune. Their immunity is the proof of their status, the validation of their identity, and the source of their joy. Thats the vital thing. If you wonder what Mrs. Clinton does with the time she doesn't spend on fundraising (and, of course, lying), I think I have an answer. She spends most of her time laughing at honest people who have a job.

About this Author Stephen Cox is editor of Liberty, and a professor of literature at the University of California San Diego. His recent books include The Big House: Image and Reality of the American Prison and American Christianity: The Continuing Revolution. Newly published is Culture and Liberty, a selection of works by Isabel Paterson.

Some recipients use services that don't support encryption (click for details)Conversation opened. 1 unread message.

Skip to content
Using Gmail with screen readers

Inbox (24,188)
Sent Mail
abcd (978)
COLLEGE (1,101)
CST111 (30)
CST112 (82)
Github (46) (1)
CST161 (50)
INFO (692)
Quora (158)
POL (6,819)
B#BAM (293)
D#Doctor (52)
H#Thumb (311)
Learnivore (10)
old (46)
P#Parliament (70)
W#Wyzant (865)
Z#,S,T,U,etc.# (202)
online (132)
S#TutorSource (102)
web (6)
WRITE (2,936)
walker (1)
wusb (12,133)
Z (299)
10 of 37,286  
Print all In new window
items for 9/20/2016

Barry Loberfeld
1:18 AM (7 hours ago)

to Bruce 
20 TUE @ 7:00
Michael Eric Dyson, author, “The Black Presidency”
(516) 463-5669

20 TUE @ 7:00
Inventors and Entrepreneurs Club
H. Lee Dennison Building

21 WED @ 11:15 am
In Defense of Political Correctness and Identity Politics
Sally Kohn, CNN commentator
(516) 463-5669

22 THU @ 11:15 am
What Issues Will Decide the 2016 Presidential Election?
Eugene Robinson and Stephen Hayes, columnists
(516) 463-5669

24 SAT @ 9:30 pm
US Elections Through Israel Eyes
Eve Harrow, Israeli councilman
Chai Center
Dix Hills

26 MON @ 9:00
Presidential Debate Watch
Cinema Arts Centre

28 WED @ 7:00
Conservative Society for Action
Moose Lodge

29 THU @ 7:00
Suffolk Libertarian Party
Hauppauge Palace Diner (back room)